While playing "Toss Up", Varshey attempted to solve the puzzle and guessed "an a moment's notice."
Sajak ruled her incorrect. Another contestant buzzed in and guessed "at a moment's notice" and won the $2,000.
Several fans of the show said Varshey was robbed and that she did say "at a moment's notice," only Sajak did not understand her accent.
While the ire was directed at Sajak, "Wheel of Fortune" does have a panel of judges who apparently decided not to step in.
Though Varshney may not have won big on "Wheel of Fortune", she has excelled in her teaching career. In 2012-2013, she was nominated for Teacher of the Year for the Academy for Allied Health Sciences.
Click here to watch the video uploaded by the NY Post.
Click here to follow Daily Voice West Milford and receive free news updates.